How often is the UK found by the European Court of Human Rights to have violated the European Convention on Human Rights, and how does its record compare with other states? This explainer by Professor Alice Donald (Middlesex University) and Dr Joelle Grogan (CEU Democracy Institute) looks at the data behind the debate, including the number of judgments against the UK, applications to the Court, interim measures and how the UK’s record has changed since the Human Rights Act came into force.
This explainer is part of the project “Human Rights: Informing the UK Debate”. The views expressed in this blog are those of the authors.
Key points
→ To date, the Court has issued one judgment finding a violation against the UK in 2026. This concerned the right to free expression of a BBC journalist who was excluded from a court hearing at the request of a private care home operator accused of mistreating residents.
→ In 2025, only a tiny proportion of UK applications decided by the Court resulted in the finding of a violation – around 1%.
→ In 2025, the Court rejected 97% of UK applications made by people or organisations in the UK claiming a violation of their rights; for example, because the applicant had not used all reasonable routes to a remedy in the UK courts, or had taken too long to apply, or their case was clearly not well-founded.
→ There has been a significant downward trend in the annual number of European Court of Human Rights judgments finding violations against the UK since the Human Rights Act 1998 began to have legal effect in 2000. The average number of judgments finding a violation by the UK in the first half of the period (2001-2012) was around 17 per year, while the average for the second half (2013-2025) was around 3.5.
How often has the European Court of Human Rights found the UK to have violated the ECHR?
The first judgment in which the Court found a violation of an ECHR right against the UK was in 1975. It established the principle that the right to a fair trial (Article 6 of the ECHR) guarantees not only a fair hearing but also the right to bring a case to court in the first place — the right of access to a court, which is now recognised as a cornerstone of the rule of law in the UK and across Europe.
In the following 50 years up to the end of 2025, the Court issued 335 judgments finding at least one violation of an ECHR right against the UK, and 154 judgments finding no violation.
The number of judgments finding violations in UK cases is less than 1.5% of the more than 26,000 judgments in which the Court has found a violation against any European state since its inception in 1959.
What is the UK’s recent record at the European Court of Human Rights?
The UK has one of the strongest human rights records among the 46 member states of the Council of Europe, and in recent years the European Court of Human Rights has very rarely found violations against the UK.
To date, the Court has issued one judgment finding a violation against the UK in 2026. In this case, the Court found that the UK had breached the right to free expression (Article 10 of the ECHR) after a BBC journalist was excluded from a Scottish court hearing so that it could be held in private at the request of the operator of a care home where residents were reported to have been mistreated. In its findings, the Court said the power to exclude the public from hearings requires "a compelling reason" and recalled that the importance of access to court proceedings for journalists is recognised by common law.
In 2025, the UK had the lowest per capita number of new applications to the Court of all the 46 states (261 new applications from people or organisations the UK were processed by the Court and allocated to judges to review).
Only a tiny proportion of UK applications decided by the Court in 2025 resulted in the finding of a violation – around 1%.
97% of UK applications decided by the Court in 2025 were found inadmissible (385 out of 397). This means that the Court rejected almost all claims of human rights violations made by people or organisations in the UK; for example, because the applicant had not used all reasonable routes to a remedy in the UK courts, or had taken too long to apply, or their case was clearly not well-founded.
Of the small number of applications found admissible that resulted in a judgment on the merits of the case in 2025, four judgments found a violation and five found no violation.
In 2025, the Court issued no interim measures against the UK, i.e. urgent injunctions made in exceptional circumstances where there is an imminent risk of irreparable harm. The Court rejected 21 requests for urgent injunctions, mostly in cases concerning expulsion and extradition.
How has the UK’s record at the European Court of Human Rights changed since the Human Rights Act?
There has been a significant downward trend in the annual number of judgments finding violations against the UK since the Human Rights Act 1998 came into force (i.e. began to have legal effect) in October 2000. The Human Rights Act incorporates ECHR rights into UK law. It was introduced to “bring rights home" - to enable people to protect their rights in domestic courts, rather than face the time and financial costs of bringing a case to the European Court of Human Rights.
The average number of European Court of Human Rights judgments finding a violation by the UK in the first half of the period (2001-2012) was around 17 per year, while the average for the second half (2013-2025) was around 3.5.
The marked reduction in the number of judgments by the Court against the UK in the past decade could reflect the impact of the HRA in three ways.
First, the HRA creates a legal obligation for all public bodies to protect rights in all their day-to-day decisions and actions, meaning that people’s rights are less likely to be breached in the first place.
Secondly, as a result of the HRA, UK courts are the first port of call for any human rights claimant, and UK judges consider human rights more explicitly and intensively than they could before. This means that fewer cases are likely to find their way to the European Court of Human Rights, because claimants are able to obtain justice through UK courts.
Thirdly, when a case does reach the Court, it is more likely to uphold the reasoning and conclusions of UK courts and the decisions of public authorities where they are informed by human rights considerations, as the HRA requires.
About the project
This explainer is part of the project “Human Rights: Informing the UK Debate”, a collaboration between the Modern Slavery and Human Rights Policy and Evidence Centre (University of Oxford), the Bonavero Institute of Human Rights (University of Oxford), and Middlesex University.
The project aims to improve the quality of public discourse on human rights by providing expert content grounded in robust evidence and rigorous analysis. It seeks to identify and respond to inaccurate or misleading reporting or commentary about human rights. It also explores what human rights mean for ordinary people in their everyday lives, and for the values they care about such as security, dignity, accountability, democracy and national sovereignty. The project is funded by a gift from the Sigrid Rausing Trust.
The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and not necessarily of the Modern Slavery and Human Rights Policy and Evidence Centre, the University of Oxford or their funders.